Consignment stores in Toronto: Seagrave's and 15 more shops

Garb at 1046 Queen St W sells most items at about 50% to 75% off original retail, and Seagrave's on Ossington is the place for menswear.

VSP at 1410 Dundas St W is the only one of these 16 shops that refunds a change of mind, on eligible online orders within 7 days. Its returns page said so on 8 November 2026.

These 16 consignment and resale shops in Toronto sell designer pieces second hand, and 12 of them print all sales final.

Seagrave's, the menswear consignment shop called I Miss You MAN from 2014 until 2026, is at 63-E Ossington Ave and at 1066 Yonge St in Summerhill. It sells designer clothing, accessories and jewellery, and its own contact page gave 12 to 6 every day at both shops on 16 October 2026. Seagrave's page on the Toronto boutique directory has the map.

The women's shop beside it, I Miss You Vintage at 63 Ossington Ave, has sold luxury designer resale and vintage couture since 2005. It opens Wednesday to Sunday, 12 to 6.

Designer second hand in Toronto splits into four errands across four parts of the city, so pick yours first. Most terms match Seagrave's: "Since all items are on consignment, all sales are final."

Quick facts

• Shops: 16 consignment and resale shops, 3 by appointment only
• All sales final: 12 of the 16, while 3 give something back
• Seagrave's: new pieces every Friday at 12
• Selling: consignors get 50% at Garb and Designer Exchange
• On within: 1,198 pre owned pieces at Utopia, 132 Cumberland St, from $50; every count, price and hour read 16 October 2026

For a bag with its papers

Lafayette Consignment sits above the Yonge and Sheppard subway station, at 4750 Yonge St, and it is where I would buy a first bag. Its Lifetime Authenticity Warranty has no time limit.

Luxury Finds Consignment, 2nd floor, 1560 Avenue Rd, opens by booking only, in 30 minute slots. Every piece is checked twice, and selected pieces then go to Entrupy, LegitGrails or Authentication First. Its founder, Christina Adamo, spent over 20 years in luxury retail.

Designer Exchange at 3a Wendover Rd prints all sales final, but will consign a piece again if it does not work out.

For a dress with a year on it, Yorkville and Mount Pleasant

The Cat's Meow at 180 Avenue Rd has been in Yorkville since 2006, and its window posts name the year, like a Fendi 1999 runway wrap skirt. The 2 October post priced a Phoebe Philo plongé leather bomber at $5,695.

Rewind Couture at 577 Mt Pleasant Rd, launched by Dawn Librach in December 2014, prints five grades, and Good, the lowest, means noticeable wear. Second Nature Boutique at 514 Mount Pleasant Rd goes back to 1974, when Ruth Silverberg opened it.

For a walk along Queen and Dundas West

Fashionably Yours at 707 Queen St W was founded in March 2009. Its Hermès guide reads the year from a letter in a circle or square, or a lone letter before 1970. Garb at 1046 Queen St W prices most pieces about 50% to 75% off original retail.

VSP Consignment at 1410 Dundas St W began as Vespucci in Calgary in 1986 and opened in Toronto in 2013. In 2019 it put more than 800 Schitt's Creek wardrobe pieces online. The Comeback at 4893 Dundas St W has done women's consignment for over 40 years and takes sizes 00 to 22.

For menswear and the archive, Ossington, Spadina and Maud St

Seagrave's, one of the shops on Ossington, is furnished with Victorian display cases, industrial factory carts, taxidermy and turn of the century barn board wainscoting. It takes pieces from the last 5 to 7 years. Its latest drop listed a Tom Ford quarter zip sweater at $595 and a Loro Piana vicuña coat at $18,995.

Boketto at 174 Ossington Ave began from a love of vintage Prada, Nepenthes and Comme des Garçons. It buys outright rather than on consignment, authenticates every piece in house and opens 12 to 7 daily (an hour past Seagrave's).

DRIEW Garments at C22, 222 Spadina Ave is the only official DEEPTI stockist in Canada. Its archive holds Rick Owens, Ann Demeulemeester and Mihara Yasuhiro, and it opens Wednesday to Sunday, 12 to 6.

20 Maud and Archive Threads share Unit B2 at 20 Maud St, by appointment. Archive Threads lists an AW03 Raf Simons parka, autumn winter 2003, at $5,985 USD, and 20 Maud an AW1997 Raf Simons knit at $2,750.

Final sale against a second chance

Mine & Yours at 79 Yorkville Ave takes back full priced clothing and shoes for store credit or an exchange within 15 days of receiving an online order. Its owner, Courtney Watkins, writes that Mine & Yours opened its doors in 2013. Rewind gives store credit within seven days for a piece tried on in store that does not fit.

At 12 of these 16 shops, the fine print is the whole return policy.

VSP alone refunds a change of mind, on eligible online orders within 7 days, which leaves me torn: in store, everything is final.

What to ask before you pay

Ask for the grade, Rewind's word or Lafayette's score out of 10. At Designer Exchange, patience pays: a piece drops 30% after a month in store, 50% after two and 75% after three.

Ask for a certificate if you plan to resell: Lafayette adds a third party certificate to any order, and Luxury Finds sells one on request. Book ahead at Luxury Finds, Lafayette and 20 Maud.

Garb ships within Canada only, Seagrave's charges $20 to the US, and Boketto $35 CAD to the rest of the world. The pre owned shelf on within states condition where Utopia graded it, and Utopia ships worldwide.

The Yorkville to Ossington shopping route joins the first errand to the last.

Common questions

What are the best consignment shops in Toronto?

Pick by errand: a bag with its papers, a dress with a year on it, a walk along Queen and Dundas West, or menswear. Lafayette suits a bag, The Cat's Meow a dress, Seagrave's menswear and Garb a walk.

Is consignment the same as thrifting?

No. A consignment shop sells your piece and pays you a share; a thrift store sells donations. In Garb's words, "We are not a thrift store."

How to sell in a consignment store?

Leave it with the shop, which pays you a share when it sells. Seagrave's pays 50% on pieces priced $100 and over and 40% on $99 and under. Boketto buys outright for 40% in cash or 60% in store credit, and where to sell designer clothes in Toronto covers the rest.

Every business above is independent, was verified open as of August 2026, and nobody paid to be here. If one has closed or moved, tell us at hello@shopwithin.co and we will fix it.

within carries the world's best boutique shelves. Toronto is open now and more cities follow. The quizzes will read your taste and the journal has the rest of the city.