Designer consignment NYC pays the most when you wait

Designer consignment in New York pays between 20 percent and 70 percent. INA in Nolita, Michael's on Madison Avenue and Designer Revival on East 81st Street all print 70 percent at the top. Stand on Madison Avenue at 11:00 with a wool coat, then walk to East 81st Street to cover three shops.

In New York the split is printed and the wait is the price. Consignment pays most and pays last, while a buying counter pays less cash and settles this week.

Wear an oversized navy trench coat with flat leather boots so you can carry three hangers without feeling worn down. within checked the published contracts, counting 162 boutiques in within's New York boutique directory on 26 September 2026.

Quick facts

• Directory count: 162 boutiques across 17 neighbourhoods on within, read 26 September 2026.
• Upper East Side cluster: 3 of the 7 shops in the neighbourhood handle consignment.
• Top consignment split: 70% above $7,500 at Michael's or $5,000 at INA.
• The shared clock: 90 days at 4 shops, 20% off after 30 days and 50% off after 60.
• Payment: Mr Goods pays within 24 hours of an accepted offer; Ron's makes a cash offer within 24 hours and pays same day cash.
• Store credit: What Goes Around Comes Around credit is worth 20% more than cash; Michael's lets the balance plus 10% be spent in store.

The Upper East Side walk

Three of the seven Upper East Side boutiques handle consignment. Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women at 1125 Madison Ave holds a 4.5 rating from 284 reviews and takes pieces seasonally. It splits 50/50 up to $4,999, 60 percent from $5,000 to $7,500, and 70 percent above $7,500, paid by check the month after sale.

At 1132 Madison Ave, La Boutique Resale occupies the 2nd and 3rd floors with a 4 rating from 97 reviews. Its contract runs about 90 days with a flat 50 percent split, mailed 30 to 50 days after purchase. Retrieving an item inside 60 days costs 20 percent of the starting price, and dry cleaning deducts at least $8.

Designer Revival at 324 East 81st Street holds a 4.5 rating from 242 reviews and takes drop offs between 12pm and 7pm. Consignors earn 20 percent to 70 percent per item, with checks mailed on the 15th for items sold the month before. A first drop off requires at least 3 pieces, with 50 percent markdowns after 60 days and a $15 early removal fee.

Downtown contracts and appointments

In Nolita, INA at 21 Prince Street holds a 4.2 rating from 52 reviews among local Nolita boutiques. It requires an in store appointment for pieces from the last 5 years, paying 40 percent under $500 and 70 percent at $5,000 and above. Among East Village boutiques, Tokio 7 at 83 E 7th St holds a 4 rating from 256 reviews and pays a flat 50 percent split by check only.

At 275 to 277 W 113th St, Trunk Show Designer Consignment accepts seasonal pieces Tuesday to Saturday by appointment only. The shop splits 50/50, drops prices 20 percent after 30 days, and marks down 50 percent after 60 days. After 90 days consignors are called to collect, and items left more than 14 days after the contract ends are donated.

Pilgrim New York at 70 Orchard Street among Lower East Side boutiques is filed consignment and does not publish a split. Hamlet's Vintage at 161 W 4th St is filed resale and does not publish a split.

Consignment splits against buyout cash

A buying counter trades payout size for speed, matching the four routes in where to sell designer clothes in Toronto. Among SoHo boutiques, What Goes Around Comes Around at 351 West Broadway holds a 3.7 rating from 202 reviews. It quotes by email within 7 to 10 business days and pays by check, or gives 20 percent more in store credit.

At 7 Maiden Ln, Mr Goods Buy & Sell holds a 4.8 rating from 925 reviews and quotes within hours. Visit the showroom or ship the piece for a same day offer, paid within 24 hours of acceptance by check, bank transfer or PayPal. In Astoria, Ron's Buy Sell Trade at 30-11 Steinway St holds a 4.9 rating from 450 reviews and pays same day cash without consignment.

17th St Luxury NYC at 18 E 17th St holds a 4.9 rating from 289 reviews and buys bags only, verifying with Entrupy. None of the four buying counters prints a percentage, so the offer is the number. On is StockX legit, read 11 September 2026, orders on the Verified Marketplace are inspected by staff or shipped by vetted sellers.

The fourth route is private sales. You can sell to a friend or on a forum, where nobody takes a fee and nobody stands behind the piece.

Consignment pays the most money only if you can afford to wait three months for the check.

What to check before you hand over a piece

Book an appointment ahead for Trunk Show or INA, and contact Michael's before carrying seasonal items uptown. Designer Revival accepts drop offs between 12pm and 7pm seven days a week. (Always ask for your itemized intake slip before you step back onto the pavement).

Check the early retrieval penalty and markdown schedule before signing any agreement. La Boutique Resale charges 20 percent of the starting price if you retrieve an item within 60 days. Designer Revival charges a $15 early removal fee plus shipping before 90 days, while Michael's gives you ten days to collect unsold pieces.

Common questions

Where can I sell designer clothes in NYC?

You can consign at Upper East Side boutiques like Michael's and Designer Revival, or sell upfront at Ron's Buy Sell Trade and Mr Goods Buy & Sell. The Upper East Side holds 3 consignment shops within walking distance of Madison Avenue.

How much do consignment stores pay in New York?

Consignment stores in New York pay between 20 percent and 70 percent of the final selling price depending on the item value. INA pays 70 percent at $5,000 and above, while Michael's pays 70 percent above $7,500. At four of them the price drops 20 percent after 30 days and 50 percent after 60.

Is it better to consign or sell for cash?

Consigning is better if you want the highest payout and can wait 90 days, while selling for cash is better if you need money within 24 hours. Consignment pays up to 70 percent because you wait for a sale, while buying counters pay less and only Ron's pays same day cash.

Every business above is independent, was verified open as of August 2026, and nobody paid to be here. If one has closed or moved, tell us at hello@shopwithin.co and we will fix it.

within opens the world's best boutique shelves on October 1. Toronto is open now and more cities follow. Until then, the quizzes will read your taste and the journal has the rest of the city.