Supreme beanie prices, and why the USD 40 one is enough

Three of the four beanies on Supreme's US shop this season cost USD 40. Paying more later gets you a box logo or a sold out collaboration, and neither one is a warmer hat. A collector will disagree, since anything sold out is worth having to them.

Quick facts

• Supreme's own price: USD 40 for the Loose Gauge, Elliott Smith and Polartec Sport beanies, USD 98 for the Suede Panel.
• Sold out at Supreme: the Elliott Smith (style BN47) and the Polartec Sport (style BN37), in every colour listed.
• Supreme's free shipping: US orders over USD 250, with some exceptions.
• After the drop: USD 70 to 210 for a resold Supreme beanie.
• On within: 275 Supreme items from CAD 30, including 30 Supreme hats from CAD 100, at two Toronto boutiques, read 13 November 2026.

For the winter buyer, the USD 40 drop

Supreme's first store opened in April 1994, in a former office space on Lafayette Street in Lower Manhattan. The plainest beanie on its US shop is the Loose Gauge (BN10), cuffed acrylic in a loose knit with the logo on the cuff. Some colours were sold out and the rest were in stock, at USD 40.

The Supreme/Elliott Smith Beanie has an embroidered graphic on the front, and the Polartec Sport Beanie is Polartec 200 fleece. Both cost USD 40 and both were sold out in every colour.

The Suede Panel Beanie (BN43) was in stock at USD 98. Its own page calls it hand crocheted acrylic with suede panels and a logo patch on the front. Supreme's US shop ships free on orders over USD 250, which one beanie will not reach alone.

For the collector, a box logo against a USD 40 hat

New Era's own story page says the company began in 1920, when Ehrhardt Koch borrowed money from his sister Rose to start it.

The black New Era Box Logo Beanie is from fall winter 2018 and costs USD 175 (CAD 250) at Utopia. Its listing calls it a pull on hat with a deep folded cuff, and the box logo is the only mark on the front. The tan Yankees Box Logo Beanie costs USD 140 (CAD 200), with a red box logo patch and white interlocking letters on the crown.

Put the black one beside the Loose Gauge and it is USD 175 against USD 40, for two cuffed beanies. The gap pays for a logo from a season that is over, and to a collector that is the whole point. If you are spending that much, read how to spot fake Supreme first.

For a gift, the odd ones

Supreme was sold to the eyewear company EssilorLuxottica in July 2024. These four are for someone who wants the odd one, not the box logo, and they are the ones I would wrap as a gift.

For USD 140 (CAD 200), the purple Cityscape Beanie has a night skyline, with small sparkling stones marking out the buildings. At USD 210 (CAD 300), the Hand Tied Beanie is chunky, in thick vertical stripes of mixed yarn with "loose tufts of yarn sticking out all over".

At Outlined, the red Bandana Big Logo Beanie sells for USD 84 (CAD 120), listed as "Brand New". Cheapest of the four is the Cycle SkullCap, USD 70 (CAD 100), with a long tie tail and a print in orange, red and brown. (I would wear it with a plain grey coat, so the print stands out.)

The hat costs USD 40. Everything past that pays for the logo or the look.

Before you pay a resale price

Utopia ships to the United States and prints "Guaranteed 100% authentic" on its pages. Its own policy says international orders arrive in 7 to 10 business days. within's shipping page lists its US shipping as free over CAD 300.

Outlined's listing says "100% Authentic", and its FAQ says it ships internationally. A US order takes 2 to 5 days to process, then up to 3 to 10 business days to arrive. US buyers may owe duties, customs or taxes on top.

For a December gift, order early and leave time for customs. If a USD 40 one is still in your colour on Supreme's shop, buy that first.

Common questions

How much is a Supreme beanie?

Supreme's own beanies cost USD 40 to 98 on its US shop, and resold ones at boutiques run USD 70 to 210. In Canadian dollars the resold ones start at CAD 100, and the note on Supreme prices in Canada covers the rest.

Do Supreme beanies sell out?

Yes, the Supreme/Elliott Smith and Polartec Sport beanies were sold out in every colour on Supreme's US shop on 13 November 2026. Some Loose Gauge colours were gone too, and the Suede Panel was still in stock.

Are Supreme beanies worth it?

At USD 40 from Supreme, yes, and above that only for a box logo or an odd one you will actually wear. I would not pay USD 175 just to keep my ears warm, but I would for a hat I loved.

Every business above is independent, was verified open as of August 2026, and nobody paid to be here. If one has closed or moved, tell us at hello@shopwithin.co and we will fix it.

within carries the world's best boutique shelves. Toronto is open now and more cities follow. The quizzes will read your taste and the journal has the rest of the city.